Self-Service Innovation at USAA

August 13, 2009

The NYT recently described an innovative new iPhone “app” that allows customers to use their phones to deposit a check.  Take pictures of the front and back of the check with the phone’s camera, and then use its email function to send the pictures to USAA.  Now discard the check.  No trip to the bank necessary. 

The application is a great model for self-service innovation.  USAA customers get a solution they prefer to the existing alternatives.  Instead of going to an ATM, they can now deposit a check from anywhere.  Customers get the enhanced convenience of mobile banking without having to sacrifice functionality.  In fact, the mobile deposit service increased the functionality of the traditional online banking experience, essentially overcoming the classic tradeoff between functionality and convenience.

USAA didn’t just transport the same services to a new channel — it designed new services for a new channel.  Bank of America, in contrast, created an iPhone application that only performs a limited set of transactions, all of which can be performed through its online banking program.  This type of solution is far more common and creates far less value for customers, a concession to the tradeoff between convenience and service.  USAA reminds us that great service innovation occurs when we challenge our employees (and often customers) to overcome persistent assumptions.


Service Excellence Defined (and Illustrated)

April 7, 2009

Service excellence can be hard to define — it often falls into the “know it when I see it” category of vague, but important distinctions.  Part of the challenge is the subjectivity of a word like excellence. Not all customers value service attributes in the same way. The intimacy you enjoy with a waiter who asks about your children and remembers how you like your burger may feel intrusive and jarring to me (hypothetically, of course).

I’d like to ground the definition of service excellence in the idea of reliability.  Service excellence is the consistent delivery of a high value/price experience, day after day, year after year, regardless of who happens to be on the front lines of the delivery process. It is the systematic output of a service model that is designed explicitly to produce it.  It is not the typical way we consume good service today, which is when entrepreneurial employees take it upon themselves to meet our needs in spite of the system.

In the spirit of know-it-when-I-see-it, I’m starting a highly subjective, incomplete list of service organizations that have reliably offered me (or people I know) excellent service.  I hope this brings the concept to life a bit. I also hope to learn from you. I would love to hear about other organizations you’d add to this list.

  • Lexus Service Centers – incredible that this level of service is possible and its competitors are choosing not to do it.
  • USAA – very difficult to find an unsatisfied customer
  • Zappos – very difficult to find an unsatisfied customer or employee
  • Wine.com – two-day shipping, scheduled at your convenience (including evenings and weekends), for $49 per year
  • Progressive Insurance – offers differentiated features such as Immediate Response vans and Total Repair
  • Four Seasons – unobtrusive excellence, if you like that sort of thing
  • J. Crew – straightforward excellence in the retail stores (thanks Kristin!)